DRIFT AUDIO
Listen to this story
Choose a voice, then press play.
Sam Darnold’s back-to-back seasons put him in a 44-man club that sounds common until you actually read the membership list.
Sam Darnold has spent most of his career being told what he isn’t. Not the guy who can carry a franchise. Not the guy a rebuilding roster should be built around. Not, according to plenty of people who watched his rookie contract play out with the New York Jets, a long term answer at quarterback anywhere.
Sam Darnold In A Seattle Seahawks Number 14 Uniform
Then he went to the Minnesota Vikings in 2024 and threw for 4,319 yards and 35 touchdowns, finished third in MVP voting, and won Comeback Player of the Year. Then he signed with the Seattle Seahawks as a free agent, and the skepticism followed him there too. The line of thinking was familiar: this would be the year the Jets version of Darnold reasserted himself over the Vikings version. Instead, Darnold threw for 4,048 yards and 25 touchdowns in the regular season, went 14 and 3, added five touchdowns and zero interceptions across three playoff games, and walked away from Super Bowl LX with a ring.
Those two seasons put Darnold in a club that sounds common until you actually look at the membership list. He is one of 44 quarterbacks in NFL history to throw for at least 4,000 yards and at least 30 touchdown passes in the same season, a combination that has become a reasonable proxy for a genuinely great year throwing the football across five different decades of the sport. Forty four names, drawn from a league that has employed thousands of starting quarterbacks since 1960, is a small enough number that knowing all of them by heart is a legitimately difficult trivia exercise, which is exactly why Yardbarker built an entire quiz around it, one that’s drawn more than 2,300 attempts and an average score of 88 percent. It’s also a good excuse to walk through what that list actually looks like, because the shape of it tells a pretty clear story about how the passing game evolved.
stir
The first two men to do it did so in the same season, and neither of them is a household name outside serious football history circles. Dan Fouts threw for 4,715 yards and 30 touchdowns for the 1980 San Diego Chargers, running Don Coryell’s vertical passing scheme against a rulebook that had only recently started protecting receivers and quarterbacks in ways that made those numbers achievable. Brian Sipe did it the same year for the Cleveland Browns, throwing for 4,132 yards and 30 scores on a team nicknamed the Kardiac Kids for how many of their games came down to the final possession.
Fouts wasn’t done. He hit the mark again in 1981 with 4,802 yards and 33 touchdowns, and the Green Bay Packers got their own entry in 1983 when Lynn Dickey threw for 4,458 yards and 32 scores. For most of the 1980s, though, this was still a short list, because it required a specific kind of quarterback in a specific kind of offense. That changed in a hurry once Dan Marino showed up.
scope
Marino’s 1984 season with the Miami Dolphins, 5,084 yards and 48 touchdowns, remains one of the most startling single seasons any quarterback has ever produced, and it did as much as any single performance to reset what the league thought was possible from a passing offense. He qualified for the 4,000 yard, 30 touchdown club four times across his career, in 1984, 1985, 1986, and 1994, tying him with Brett Favre for the most all time until a later generation blew past both of them.
Warren Moon got there twice, in 1990 with the run and shoot Houston Oilers and again in 1995 after a trade to Minnesota, throwing for a combined 4,689 and 4,228 yards in those two years. Steve Young did it in 1998 with the San Francisco 49ers. Kurt Warner did it three times, including a ridiculous 1999 season for the Greatest Show on Turf St. Louis Rams(4,353 yards, 41 touchdowns) and an even bigger yardage total in 2001 (4,830 yards, 36 touchdowns). Brett Favre added entries in 1995, 1998, and 2004, all with Green Bay, spread across a career long enough to touch three different decades of quarterback play.
By the end of the 1990s, the club had gone from a novelty to something closer to a normal marker of an elite season, but it still wasn’t an annual occurrence around the league. That took one more shift.
frequent
Four names account for a wildly disproportionate share of the entire list, and they’re exactly the four you’d guess. Drew Brees and Peyton Manning are tied at the top with nine qualifying seasons apiece, an absurd number that reflects both their individual greatness and the fact that they played the bulk of their careers in an era when rule changes on illegal contact and defenseless receivers had swung hard in favor of the passing game. Manning got his first in 2000 with the Indianapolis Colts and kept collecting them through his final MVP caliber years with the Denver Broncos. Brees started his run with the New Orleans Saints and barely slowed down into his late 30s, piling up 5,000 yard seasons that would have qualified him for this list several times over even before accounting for the years he only hit 4,000.
Tom Brady is next with eight qualifying seasons, including his record setting 2007 campaign with the New England Patriots (4,806 yards, 50 touchdowns) that briefly made Marino’s 1984 season look almost normal by comparison. Aaron Rodgers has seven, built during a stretch in Green Bay when he was arguably the most efficient deep ball thrower the league had ever seen. Philip Rivers rounds out the group with six, a total that tends to surprise people given how rarely Rivers gets mentioned in the same breath as the other three, despite spending most of a decade with the Chargers producing numbers that belong in the same conversation.
Peyton Manning And Drew Brees In Their NFL Uniforms
Between them, those four quarterbacks account for 30 of the roughly 90 some individual qualifying seasons that have happened across NFL history, which says something about how concentrated this kind of excellence has been even within an exclusive club. It’s not just that 44 players have done it. It’s that a huge share of the times it’s happened, it happened to one of four guys.
next
A tier of active and recently active quarterbacks sits at four qualifying seasons apiece: Dak Prescott of the Dallas Cowboys, Jared Goff of the Detroit Lions, Patrick Mahomes of the Kansas City Chiefs, and Matthew Stafford. Mahomes’ inclusion is a little deceptive, since his ceiling is obviously much higher than four total seasons suggests. He’s simply been so good in the touchdown column and efficient enough in the yardage column across a career built around winning championships rather than chasing counting stats that four is where he currently sits, with plenty of runway left to climb toward Brees and Manning territory.
Stafford has been remarkably durable about clearing this bar across three different franchises’ worth of good and bad supporting casts, dating back to his Lions years. Goff’s inclusion reflects a genuine second act renaissance back in Detroit after his rocky ending with the Rams. Prescott has quietly built a resume in Dallas that rivals or exceeds most of his more hyped contemporaries when you actually line the numbers up side by side.
One step below them, at three seasons each, sits a group that includes Josh Allen of the Buffalo Bills, Joe Burrow of the Cincinnati Bengals, Russell Wilson, Kirk Cousins, Andrew Luck, Matt Ryan, and Eli Manning, alongside holdovers like Warner and Favre from the earlier tiers. Allen and Burrow both feel like locks to keep climbing given where their careers currently stand. Luck’s three seasons with the Colts are a reminder of how good he was before injuries ended his career early, a what could have been case that gets less attention than it probably deserves in these conversations. Eli Manning’s presence on this list, three qualifying seasons with the New York Giants across a career that also delivered two Super Bowl upsets over undefeated or heavily favored Patriots teams, is the kind of detail that tends to catch people off guard when the quiz forces them to actually recall it.
fin
The most interesting part of the list, at least for quiz purposes, is the group of roughly 20 quarterbacks who have done it exactly once. This is where Darnold currently sits, alongside names spanning the entire history of the category: Scott Mitchell’s surprising 1995 season with the Lions, Vinny Testaverde’s 1996 with the Baltimore Ravens, Steve Beuerlein’s 1999 with the Carolina Panthers, Jeff Garcia’s 2000 with the 49ers, Daunte Culpepper’s monster 2004 season with the Vikings (4,717 yards, 39 touchdowns, the kind of year that still holds up statistically two decades later), Blake Bortles’ single qualifying season with the Jacksonville Jaguars, and Jameis Winston, Andy Dalton, Deshaun Watson, Baker Mayfield, Geno Smith, Lamar Jackson, Jordan Love, and Brock Purdy representing the more recent additions.
Drake Maye’s name on that list, from his 2025 season with the Patriots, is the newest addition and the one that points most directly at where this list goes next. A young quarterback putting together a qualifying season in year two of his career is exactly the profile that historically graduates from the one and done tier into the multi season club a few years later, the same path Mahomes, Allen, and Burrow all walked before they became fixtures near the top of the leaderboard.
Darnold’s case is a little different from most of the one timers, because his 2024 season with Minnesota technically didn’t need Seattle’s 2025 campaign to qualify. He’s actually got a real shot at becoming a repeat member rather than a permanent resident of the single season group, especially if Seattle’s offense stays built around the personnel that made Jaxon Smith Njigba the league’s leading receiver and produced a five touchdown, zero interception ratio across three playoff games.
None of that guarantees a third qualifying season. Seattle’s 2026 schedule is built to test exactly the kind of consistency that got Darnold here, with a Super Bowl LX rematch on the calendar, road trips against the Chicago Bears and Denver, a visit from the Philadelphia Eagles, and a full slate of games against a division that a lot of preseason polling now considers the toughest in football, largely because the Los Angeles Rams are widely projected as the team most likely to end Seattle’s reign. What Darnold has going for him is that his statistical path to a third qualifying season doesn’t require a career year. His 2025 total of 4,048 yards left comparatively little margin, but a full 17 game season with even modest improvement in his touchdown rate puts him back over both thresholds fairly comfortably, health and game script permitting.
Either way, Darnold has already done enough to guarantee his name shows up on next year’s version of this same quiz, whether or not he adds a third qualifying season to his resume. Whether he shows up as one of the answers people forget, or moves into the tier alongside Fouts, Moon, and Rivers, is the exact kind of question this list exists to keep track of.
